1 Corinthians 15:29

King James Version (KJV)

Else what shall they do which are baptized for the dead, if the dead rise not at all? why are they then baptized for the dead?

Adam Clarke
Bible Commentary

Else what shall they do which are baptized for the dead - This is certainly the most difficult verse in the New Testament; for, notwithstanding the greatest and wisest men have labored to explain it, there are to this day nearly as many different interpretations of it as there are interpreters. I shall not employ my time, nor that of my reader, with a vast number of discordant and conflicting opinions; I shall make a few remarks:

The doctrine of the resurrection of our Lord was a grand doctrine among the apostles; they considered and preached this as the demonstration of the truth of the Gospel.

The multitudes who embraced Christianity became converts on the evidence of this resurrection.

This resurrection was considered the pledge and proof of the resurrection of all believers in Christ to the possession of the same glory into which he had entered.

The baptism which they received they considered as an emblem of their natural death and resurrection. This doctrine St. Paul most pointedly preaches, Romans 6:3-5; : Know ye not that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ, were baptized into his death? Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death; that like as Christ was raised up from the dead, even so we also should walk in newness of life: for, if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also in his resurrection.

It is evident from this that all who died in the faith of Christ died in the faith of the resurrection; and therefore cheerfully gave up their lives to death, as they took joyfully the spoiling of their goods, knowing in themselves that they had in heaven a better and an enduring substance, Hebrews 10:34.

As is the body, so are the members; those who were properly instructed, and embraced Christianity, believed that as all who had died in the faith of Christ should rise again, so they were baptized in the same faith.

As so many of the primitive followers of Christ sealed the truth with their blood, and Satan and his followers continued unchanged, every man who took on him the profession of Christianity, which was done by receiving baptism, considered himself as exposing his life to the most imminent hazard, and offering his life with those who had already offered and laid down theirs.

He was therefore baptized in reference to this martyrdom; and, having a regard to those dead, he cheerfully received baptism, that, whether he were taken off by a natural or violent death, he might be raised in the likeness of Jesus Christ's resurrection, and that of his illustrious martyrs.

As martyrdom and baptism were thus so closely and intimately connected, βαπτιζεσθαι, to be baptized, was used to express being put to a violent death by the hands of persecutors. So Matthew 20:22, Matthew 20:23; : "But Jesus answered and said, Are ye able to drink of the cup that I shall drink of? etc." (Can ye go through my sufferings?) "They say unto him, We are able. He saith unto them, Ye shall indeed drink of my cup," (ye shall bear your part of the afflictions of the Gospel), "and be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with (that is, ye shall suffer martyrdom.) See also Mark 10:38. So Luke 12:50; "I have a baptism to be baptized with; and how am I straitened till it be accomplished!" That is, I must die a violent death for the salvation of men.

10. The sum of the apostle's meaning appears to be this: If there be no resurrection of the dead, those who, in becoming Christians, expose themselves to all manner of privations, crosses, severe sufferings, and a violent death, can have no compensation, nor any motive sufficient to induce them to expose themselves to such miseries. But as they receive baptism as an emblem of death in voluntarily going under the water, so they receive it as an emblem of the resurrection unto eternal life, in coming up out of the water; thus they are baptized for the dead, in perfect faith of the resurrection. The three following verses seem to confirm this sense.

Was this helpful?

Albert Barnes
Notes on the Whole Bible

Else what shall they do … - The apostle here resumes the argument for the resurrection which was interrupted at 1 Corinthians 15:19. He goes on to state further consequences which must follow from the denial of this doctrine, and thence infers that the doctrine must be true. There is, perhaps, no passage of the New Testament in respect to which there has been a greater variety of interpretation than this; and the views of expositors now by no means harmonize in regard to its meaning. It is possible that Paul may here refer to some practice or custom which existed in his time respecting baptism, the knowledge of which is now lost. The various opinions which have been entertained in regard to this passage, together with an examination of them, may be seen in Pool‘s Synopsis, Rosenmuller, and Bloomfield. It may be not useless just to refer to some of them, that the perplexity of commentators may be seen:

(1) It has been held by some that by “the dead” here is meant the Messiah who was put to death, the plural being used for the singular, meaning “the dead one.”

(2) by others, that the word “baptized” here is taken in the sense of washing, cleansing, purifying, as in Matthew 8:4; Hebrews 9:10; and that the sense is, that the dead were carefully washed and purified when buried, with the hope of the resurrection, and, as it were, preparatory to that.

(3) by others, that to be “baptized for the dead” means to be baptized as dead, being baptized into Christ, and buried with him in baptism, and that by their immersion they were regarded as dead.

(4) by others, that the apostle refers to a custom of vicarious baptism, or being baptized for those who were dead, referring to the practice of having some person baptized in the place of one who had died without baptism. This was the opinion of Grotius, Michaelis, Tertullian, and Ambrose. Such was the estimate which was formed, it is supposed, of the importance of baptism, that when one had died without being baptized, some other person was baptized over his dead body in his place. That this custom prevailed in the church after the time of Paul, has been abundantly proved by Grotius, and is generally admitted. But the objections to this interpretation are obvious:

(a)There is no evidence that such a custom prevailed in the time of Paul.

(b)It cannot be believed that Paul would give countenance to a custom so senseless and so contrary to the Scripture, or that he would make it the foundation of a solemn argument.

(c)It does not accord with the strain and purpose of his argument. If this custom had been referred to, his design would have led him to say, “What will become of them for whom others have been baptized? Are we to believe that they have perished?”

(d)It is far more probable that the custom referred to in this opinion arose from an erroneous interpretation of this passage of Scripture, than that it existed in the time of Paul.

(5) there remain two other opinions, both of which are plausible, and one of which is probably the true one. One is, that the word baptized is used here as it is in Matthew 20:22-23; Mark 10:39; Luke 12:50, in the sense of being overwhelmed with calamities, trials, and sufferings; and as meaning that the apostles and others were subjected to great trials on account of the dead, that is, in the hope of the resurrection; or with the expectation that the dead would rise. This is the opinion of Lightfoot, Rosenmuller, Pearce, Homberg, Krause, and of Prof. Robinson (see the Lexicon article Βαπτίζω Baptizō), and has much that is plausible. That the word is thus used to denote a deep sinking into calamities, there can be no doubt. And that the apostles and early Christians subjected themselves, or were subjected to great and overwhelming calamities on account of the hope of the resurrection, is equally clear. This interpretation, also, agrees with the general tenor of the argument; and is an argument for the resurrection. And it implies that this was the full and constant belief of all who endured these trials, that there would be a resurrection of the dead. The argument would be, that they should be slow to adopt an opinion which would imply that all their sufferings were endured for nothing, and that God had supported them in this in vain; that God had plunged them into all these sorrows, and had sustained them in them only to disappoint them. That this view is plausible, and that it suits the strain of remark in the following verses, is evident. But there are objections to it:

(a)It is not the usual and natural meaning of the word “baptize.”

(b)A metaphorical use of a word should not be resorted to unless necessary.

(c)The literal meaning of the word here will as well meet the design of the apostle as the metaphorical.

(d)This interpretation does not relieve us from any of the difficulties in regard to the phrase “for the dead;” and,

(e)It is altogether more natural to suppose that the apostle would derive his argument from the baptism of all who were Christians, than from the figurative baptism of a few who went into the perils of martyrdom - The other opinion, therefore, is, that the apostle here refers to baptism as administered to all believers.

This is the most correct opinion; is the most simple, and best meets the design of the argument. According to this, it means that they had been baptized with the hope and expectation of a resurrection of the dead. They had received this as one of the leading doctrines of the gospel when they were baptized. It was a part of their full and firm belief that the dead would rise. The argument according to this interpretation is, that this was an essential article of the faith of a Christian; that it was embraced by all; that it constituted a part of their very profession; and that for anyone to deny it was to deny that which entered into the very foundation of the Christian faith.

If they embraced a different doctrine, if they denied the doctrine of the resurrection, they struck a blow at the very nature of Christianity, and dashed all the hopes which had been cherished and expressed at their baptism. And what could they do? What would become of them! What would be the destiny of all who were thus baptized? Was it to be believed that all their hopes at baptism were vain and that they would all perish? As such a belief could not be entertained, the apostle infers that, if they held to Christianity at all, they must hold to this doctrine as a part of their very profession. According to this view, the phrase “for the dead” means, with reference to the dead; with direct allusion to the condition of the dead, and their hopes; with a belief that the dead will rise. It is evident that the passage is elliptical, and this seems to be as probable as any interpretation which has been suggested. Mr. Locke says, frankly, “What this baptizing for the dead was, I know not; but it seems, by the following verses, to be something wherein they exposed themselves to the danger of death.” Tyndal translates it, “over the dead.” Doddridge renders it, “in the room of the dead, who are just fallen in the cause of Christ, but are yet supported by a succession of new converts, who immediately offer themselves to fill up their places, as ranks of soldiers that advance to the combat in the room of their companions who have just been slain in their sight.”

Was this helpful?

Matthew Henry
Concise Bible Commentary

All that are by faith united to Christ, are by his resurrection assured of their own. As through the sin of the first Adam, all men became mortal, because all had from him the same sinful nature, so, through the resurrection of Christ, shall all who are made to partake of the Spirit, and the spiritual nature, revive, and live for ever. There will be an order in the resurrection. Christ himself has been the first-fruits; at his coming, his redeemed people will be raised before others; at the last the wicked will rise also. Then will be the end of this present state of things. Would we triumph in that solemn and important season, we must now submit to his rule, accept his salvation, and live to his glory. Then shall we rejoice in the completion of his undertaking, that God may receive the whole glory of our salvation, that we may for ever serve him, and enjoy his favour. What shall those do, who are baptized for the dead, if the dead rise not at all? Perhaps baptism is used here in a figure, for afflictions, sufferings, and martyrdom, as Mt 20:22,23. What is, or will become of those who have suffered many and great injuries, and have even lost their lives, for this doctrine of the resurrection, if the dead rise not at all? Whatever the meaning may be, doubtless the apostle's argument was understood by the Corinthians. And it is as plain to us that Christianity would be a foolish profession, if it proposed advantage to themselves by their faithfulness to God; and to have our fruit to holiness, that our end may be everlasting life. But we must not live like beasts, as we do not die like them. It must be ignorance of God that leads any to disbelieve the resurrection and future life. Those who own a God and a providence, and observe how unequal things are in the present life, how frequently the best men fare worst, cannot doubt as to an after-state, where every thing will be set to rights. Let us not be joined with ungodly men; but warn all around us, especially children and young persons, to shun them as a pestilence. Let us awake to righteousness, and not sin.

Was this helpful?

SDA Bible Commentary (limited)
Volume 1-7

29. Else. Or, “otherwise.” Paul here returns to his main line of reasoning concerning the resurrection.

Baptized for the dead. This is one of the difficult passages in Paul’s writings, for which no entirely satisfactory explanation has yet been found. Commentators have produced as many as 36 attempted solutions to the problems raised by the verse. Most of the suggestions deserve but little notice, a few merit serious attention. Two important points should be borne in mind when seeking an understanding of the passage: (1) Paul is still speaking of the resurrection, and any suggested solution should be closely connected with the main theme of ch. 15. (2) A reasonable interpretation must conform with a correct translation of the Greek phrase huper t?n nekr?n (“for the dead”). It is generally agreed that huper (“for”) here means, “on behalf of.” Three possible interpretations are suggested:

(1) The passage should be translated “What then shall they do who are baptized? [Are they baptized] for the dead? If the dead do not rise again at all, why are they even baptized? Why also are we in danger every hour for them?” This translation, though possible, does not satisfactorily explain the phrase “on behalf of the dead.”

(2) Paul is referring to a heretical custom whereby living Christians were baptized on behalf of dead and unbaptized relatives or friends, who were supposed thus to be saved by proxy. Church Fathers make several references to such a practice, quoting the custom of the Marcionite heretics (Tertullian Against Marcion v. 10; On the Resurrection of the Flesh 48; Chrysostom Homilies on 1 Corinthians xl. 1). In addition, Tertullian refers to the pagan festival Kalendae Februariae, wherein worshipers underwent a lustration, or washing, on behalf of the dead (Against Marcion v. 10). Marcion flourished about the middle of the 2d century a.d. This second view requires the assumption that the practice dates back to Paul’s day. The objection has been raised that the apostle would be unlikely to cite a pagan or heretical practice in support of a fundamental Christian doctrine. But Paul, without in any way endorsing the practice, might say, in substance: “Even pagans and heretics fasten their faith on the hope of a resurrection, and if they cherish that hope, how much more should we” Jesus used the story of the Rich Man and Lazarus as the framework for a parable, though not endorsing its literal application (see on Luke 16:19).

(3) It is possible to interpret v. 29 in terms of its context (vs. 12-32) as another proof of the resurrection: (1) The word “else” refers to the argument of vs. 12-28 and might be paraphrased, “but if there is no resurrection ?” (2) The word “baptized” is used figuratively of braving extreme danger or death, as in Matt. 20:22; Luke 12:50. (3) “They ? which are baptized” refers to the apostles, constantly facing death as they proclaimed the hope of the resurrection (1 Cor. 4:9-13; cf. Rom. 8:36; 2 Cor. 4:8-12). Of his own experiences at Ephesus?where Paul wrote this epistle?he declared that he stood “in jeopardy every hour” (1 Cor. 15:30), “despaired even of life” (2 Cor. 1:8-10), and, as it were, died “daily” (1 Cor. 15:31). (4) “The dead” of v. 29 are the Christian dead of vs. 12-18, and, potentially, all living Christians, who, according to some at Corinth, had no hope beyond death (vs. 12, 19). According to this interpretation, v. 29 could be paraphrased thus: “but if there is no resurrection, what shall the messengers of the gospel do, if they continually brave death on behalf of men who are destined to perish at death anyway?” It would be folly (v. 17) for them to face death to save others, “if the dead rise not” (vs. 16, 32). The continued courage of the apostles in the face of death is thus excellent evidence of their faith in the resurrection.

That it is not possible, as some teach, for Christians to be baptized vicariously on behalf of deceased relatives and friends is apparent from the many Scriptures which declare that a man must personally believe in Christ and confess his sins in order to profit by baptism and be saved (Acts 2:38; 8:36, 37; cf. Eze. 18:20-24; John 3:16; 1 John 1:9). Even the most righteous of men can “deliver but their own souls” (Eze. 14:14, 16; cf. Ps. 49:7). Death marks the close of human probation (see Ps. 49:7-9; Eccl. 9:5, 6, 10; Isa. 38:18, 19; Luke 16:26; Heb. 9:27, 28).

Was this helpful?

SDA Bible Commentary (limited)
Volume 1-7

29. Else. Or, “otherwise.” Paul here returns to his main line of reasoning concerning the resurrection.

Baptized for the dead. This is one of the difficult passages in Paul’s writings, for which no entirely satisfactory explanation has yet been found. Commentators have produced as many as 36 attempted solutions to the problems raised by the verse. Most of the suggestions deserve but little notice, a few merit serious attention. Two important points should be borne in mind when seeking an understanding of the passage: (1) Paul is still speaking of the resurrection, and any suggested solution should be closely connected with the main theme of ch. 15. (2) A reasonable interpretation must conform with a correct translation of the Greek phrase huper tÃ…Ân nekrÃ…Ân (“for the dead”). It is generally agreed that huper (“for”) here means, “on behalf of.” Three possible interpretations are suggested:

(3) It is possible to interpret v. 29 in terms of its context (vs. 12-32) as another proof of the resurrection: (1) The word “else” refers to the argument of vs. 12-28 and might be paraphrased, “but if there is no resurrection Ã¢â‚¬Â¦” (2) The word “baptized” is used figuratively of braving extreme danger or death, as in Matt. 20:22; Luke 12:50. (3) “They Ã¢â‚¬Â¦ which are baptized” refers to the apostles, constantly facing death as they proclaimed the hope of the resurrection (1 Cor. 4:9-13; cf. Rom. 8:36; 2 Cor. 4:8-12). Of his own experiences at EphesusÃ¢â‚¬â€where Paul wrote this epistleÃ¢â‚¬â€he declared that he stood “in jeopardy every hour” (1 Cor. 15:30), “despaired even of life” (2 Cor. 1:8-10), and, as it were, died “daily” (1 Cor. 15:31). (4) “The dead” of v. 29 are the Christian dead of vs. 12-18, and, potentially, all living Christians, who, according to some at Corinth, had no hope beyond death (vs. 12, 19). According to this interpretation, v. 29 could be paraphrased thus: “but if there is no resurrection, what shall the messengers of the gospel do, if they continually brave death on behalf of men who are destined to perish at death anyway?” It would be folly (v. 17) for them to face death to save others, “if the dead rise not” (vs. 16, 32). The continued courage of the apostles in the face of death is thus excellent evidence of their faith in the resurrection.

Was this helpful?

Cross References

what

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered

A PHP Error was encountered